Pros and Cons of Using 1031 Exchange

Written by True Tamplin, BSc, CEPF®

Reviewed by Subject Matter Experts

Updated on September 08, 2023

Get Any Financial Question Answered

Pros of Using 1031 Exchange

Deferred Taxes

A 1031 Exchange, often simply termed as an "exchange," offers investors a golden ticket to defer their capital gains taxes.

When an investor sells a property, the profits are usually subject to taxation. However, using this mechanism, those taxes can be postponed, potentially leading to substantial tax savings.

Over time, the compound effect of these deferred taxes can significantly amplify the overall returns on investment.

Asset Growth

Beyond mere tax benefits, the 1031 Exchange opens the door for more substantial asset growth.

Since investors can reinvest the full amount from the sale without deductions from the capital gains tax, they can often invest in a bigger or more profitable property. This snowball effect can lead to immense wealth creation over multiple exchanges.

Portfolio Diversification

A varied real estate portfolio spreads risk. The 1031 Exchange is like a magic wand allowing investors to reshape and diversify their real estate assets without the immediate tax bite.

Whether an investor wants to switch from land to residential properties or from a single large property to multiple smaller ones, the exchange offers that flexibility without fiscal penalties.


The 1031 Exchange isn't just about growing bigger; it's about adjusting to one's changing investment strategies and needs.

Maybe an investor wants to consolidate multiple properties into one or diversify a single asset into several. With this provision, they get the flexibility to make these moves optimally.

Preservation of Capital

By not taking out a significant chunk of taxes, more capital remains in play. The beauty of the 1031 Exchange lies in its ability to preserve the capital, ensuring that the investor has more money to reinvest. This can lead to an exponential increase in property value over time.

Estate Planning Tool

Strategically, this exchange can also serve as an essential tool for estate planning.

By continually rolling properties into new ones, an investor can potentially leave a legacy of valuable real estate to their heirs, with a step-up in basis, minimizing the capital gains taxes the heirs would owe.

Increased Cash Flow

By strategically exchanging a non-performing or underperforming property for one with a higher income potential, investors can enjoy a more significant cash flow. It's not just about property appreciation; it's also about monthly revenue.

Facilitates Long-Term Growth

The 1031 Exchange is like a catalyst that fuels long-term growth in the real estate realm. With each successive exchange, the investor can climb the ladder, ensuring long-term property appreciation and wealth generation.

Geographic Relocation

Market trends shift, and regions that were once lukewarm can become hot investment zones. With the 1031 Exchange, investors can maneuver their assets toward these high-growth areas without incurring immediate tax penalties.

Stimulates Economic Activity

Beyond personal benefits, the 1031 Exchange plays a broader economic role. By fostering more real estate transactions, it indirectly contributes to job creation, boosts related industries, and drives economic growth.

Cons of Using 1031 Exchange

Complex Rules and Regulations

The 1031 Exchange isn't a free-for-all. A maze of rules and regulations surrounds it. A single misstep can disqualify the entire exchange, potentially leading to unexpected and hefty tax liabilities. This complexity often necessitates professional assistance, adding to the process's cost.

Time Constraints

This isn't an exchange where investors can take their sweet time. There's a stringent 45-day window for identifying a replacement property post the sale of the original one.

Plus, the entire exchange, from sale to purchase, must be completed in 180 days. These tight timeframes can add undue stress.

Pressure to Reinvest

Given the time constraints, investors might feel pressured to reinvest quickly, sometimes leading them into less-than-ideal deals. It's a race against time, where due diligence can sometimes take a backseat.

Potential for Future Tax Increases

Deferring taxes doesn't mean they disappear. And if tax rates climb in the future, investors might find themselves hit with an even heftier bill when they eventually decide to cash out and not reinvest.

Costs and Fees

Although you're deferring taxes, the 1031 Exchange isn't free. Hiring qualified intermediaries, consultants, and sometimes legal assistance can add up, chipping away at the potential benefits.

Limited to Like-Kind Properties

The term 'like-kind' might sound broad, but it's restrictive. Investors can't just exchange any property for another; they must be of the same nature or character, even if they differ in quality or grade.

Potential Overpricing

Savvy sellers, knowing that buyers using the 1031 Exchange are under time pressure, might hike property prices, exploiting the buyer's urgency.

Deferred, Not Eliminated Taxes

While deferring taxes is beneficial, it's essential to remember they're just postponed. Unless one plans on never cashing out or employs strategies like leaving the properties to heirs (who get a step-up in basis) or donating to charity, those taxes will come knocking.

Potential Market Risks

The rush to reinvest can sometimes blind investors to potential market downturns. In the urgency to beat the clock, they might buy at the peak, leading to potential future losses.

Liquidity Concerns

Rolling over proceeds into a new property means that capital is tied up, which could pose challenges for investors needing liquidity for other opportunities or emergencies.

Pros and Cons of Using 1031 Exchange

Bottom Line

The 1031 Exchange, rooted in the U.S. tax code, stands as a robust tool for real estate investors, offering unparalleled benefits from deferring capital gains taxes to facilitating dynamic portfolio management.

By enabling the full reinvestment of sales proceeds, investors witness amplified asset growth and portfolio diversification. Yet, while the mechanism paves the way for increased cash flow and long-term growth, it's not without its challenges.

Strict time frames, coupled with intricate rules, can make navigation daunting. Additionally, the potential for overpricing and future tax rate spikes underscores the need for thorough foresight.

In essence, while the 1031 Exchange remains a potent strategy for wealth creation and capital preservation in the real estate realm, investors must approach it with diligence, understanding both its expansive potential and inherent intricacies.

Pros and Cons of Using 1031 Exchange FAQs

About the Author

True Tamplin, BSc, CEPF®

True Tamplin is a published author, public speaker, CEO of UpDigital, and founder of Finance Strategists.

True is a Certified Educator in Personal Finance (CEPF®), author of The Handy Financial Ratios Guide, a member of the Society for Advancing Business Editing and Writing, contributes to his financial education site, Finance Strategists, and has spoken to various financial communities such as the CFA Institute, as well as university students like his Alma mater, Biola University, where he received a bachelor of science in business and data analytics.

To learn more about True, visit his personal website or view his author profiles on Amazon, Nasdaq and Forbes.

Search for Local Tax Preparers