Portfolio Attribution Analysis

true-tamplin_2x_mam3b7

Written by True Tamplin, BSc, CEPF®

Reviewed by Subject Matter Experts

Updated on January 24, 2024

Are You Retirement Ready?

Definition and Purpose of Portfolio Attribution Analysis

Portfolio attribution analysis is a quantitative method used by investment managers to evaluate the performance of a portfolio by comparing it against a benchmark.

It helps identify the sources of excess return, or "alpha," by breaking down the active return into various attribution effects.

This analysis assists investment managers in understanding the drivers of portfolio performance, evaluating their investment strategies, and communicating results to clients.

Importance in Investment Management

Effective portfolio attribution analysis enables investment managers to:

  • Evaluate their investment decisions by isolating the impact of security selection, asset allocation, and other factors.

  • Identify areas for improvement in their investment process.

  • Enhance risk management by understanding the sources of portfolio risk.

  • Communicate their investment strategies' effectiveness to clients and stakeholders.

Key Components of Portfolio Attribution Analysis

To conduct a portfolio attribution analysis, it is essential to understand its key components:

Key Components of Portfolio Attribution Analysis

Portfolio Returns

Portfolio returns represent the total return generated by the portfolio over a specific evaluation period, including capital gains, dividends, and interest.

Benchmark Returns

Benchmark returns are the returns of a selected benchmark, which serves as a performance comparison for the portfolio. This benchmark is typically a market index that represents the investment universe of the portfolio.

Active Returns

Active returns, also known as excess returns or relative returns, are the difference between the portfolio returns and the benchmark returns. They indicate the additional value generated by the investment manager's decisions.

Portfolio Weights and Benchmark Weights

Portfolio weights and benchmark weights represent the proportion of each asset or sector in the portfolio and the benchmark, respectively. These weights are used to assess the impact of asset allocation decisions on portfolio performance.

Security-Level Returns

Security-level returns are the individual returns of each security in the portfolio and the benchmark. They are used to evaluate the impact of security selection decisions on portfolio performance.

Types of Attribution Models

There are various attribution models used by investment managers to conduct portfolio attribution analysis:

Types of Attribution Models

Brinson-Fachler Model

The Brinson-Fachler model, also known as the three-factor model, breaks down active return into three components: allocation effect, selection effect, and interaction effect.

Allocation Effect

The allocation effect measures the impact of asset allocation decisions on the active return. It reflects the difference between the portfolio weights and benchmark weights, multiplied by the benchmark returns.

Selection Effect

The selection effect measures the impact of security selection decisions on the active return. It reflects the difference between the portfolio returns and benchmark returns for each security, multiplied by the portfolio weights.

Interaction Effect

The interaction effect measures the combined impact of allocation and selection decisions on the active return. It is calculated as the product of the differences in portfolio and benchmark weights and the differences in portfolio and benchmark returns.

Brinson-Hood-Beebower Model

The Brinson-Hood-Beebower model, or the two-factor model, is a simplified version of the Brinson-Fachler model. It breaks down active return into two components: allocation effect and selection effect, ignoring the interaction effect.

Karnosky-Singer Model

The Karnosky-Singer model is a global attribution model that separates the active return into two components: global attribution and currency attribution.

Global Attribution

Global attribution measures the impact of security selection and asset allocation decisions on the active return, excluding the currency effect.

Currency Attribution

Currency attribution measures the impact of currency exposure decisions on the active return, including both the direct currency effect and the indirect effect through security selection.

Risk-Adjusted Attribution Models

Risk-adjusted attribution models incorporate risk factors into the analysis to provide a more comprehensive assessment of portfolio performance. Some popular risk-adjusted attribution models are:

Treynor-Black Model

The Treynor-Black model measures the portfolio's performance by comparing the risk-adjusted active return to the benchmark's risk-adjusted return. This model takes into account the portfolio's systematic risk, or beta, and its unsystematic risk, or alpha.

Information Ratio

The information ratio measures the portfolio's active return per unit of active risk, or tracking error, compared to the benchmark. A higher information ratio indicates better risk-adjusted performance.

Steps in Conducting Portfolio Attribution Analysis

To conduct a portfolio attribution analysis, investment managers should follow these steps:

Steps in Conducting Portfolio Attribution Analysis

Identify the Portfolio and Benchmark

Determine the portfolio and the benchmark that will be used for comparison. The chosen benchmark should be representative of the investment universe and strategy of the portfolio.

Determine the Evaluation Period

Choose an appropriate evaluation period for the analysis. This period should be long enough to capture the investment manager's decisions and provide a meaningful assessment of performance.

Collect Necessary Data

Gather the required data, including portfolio and benchmark returns, weights, and security-level returns for the evaluation period.

Choose an Appropriate Attribution Model

Select an attribution model that best fits the investment strategy and objectives of the portfolio.

Calculate Attribution Effects

Using the chosen attribution model, calculate the allocation, selection, and other attribution effects that contribute to the portfolio's active return.

Interpret Results and Draw Conclusions

Analyze the calculated attribution effects to understand the drivers of portfolio performance and identify areas for improvement or adjustment in the investment strategy.

Applications and Uses of Portfolio Attribution Analysis

Portfolio attribution analysis can be used for various purposes in the investment management process:

Performance Evaluation

Investment managers can use portfolio attribution analysis to evaluate their portfolio's performance by comparing it against a benchmark, identifying the sources of excess return, and understanding the impact of their investment decisions.

Investment Strategy Assessment

By analyzing the drivers of portfolio performance, investment managers can assess the effectiveness of their investment strategy and make adjustments to improve future performance.

Risk Management

Understanding the sources of portfolio risk through attribution analysis can help investment managers enhance their risk management processes, ensuring that risks are taken in line with their investment objectives.

Client Communication and Reporting

Portfolio attribution analysis provides investment managers with a transparent and structured framework for communicating their investment strategies' effectiveness and performance to clients and stakeholders.

Limitations and Challenges of Portfolio Attribution Analysis

Despite its usefulness, portfolio attribution analysis has some limitations and challenges:

Model Limitations

Attribution models may not capture all aspects of a portfolio's performance or may make simplifying assumptions that can affect the accuracy of the analysis.

Data Availability and Quality

Attribution analysis relies on accurate and timely data. Data availability and quality can be a challenge, particularly for complex or illiquid assets.

Time Horizon Considerations

The chosen evaluation period can influence the results of the attribution analysis. Shorter periods may be subject to noise and random fluctuations, while longer periods may not capture recent changes in investment strategy or market conditions.

Benchmark Selection and Construction

The selection and construction of an appropriate benchmark can be challenging, as it should be representative of the investment universe and strategy of the portfolio.

Conclusion

Portfolio attribution analysis plays a crucial role in investment management by helping investment managers evaluate their portfolio's performance, assess their investment strategies, and communicate their results to clients.

Understanding the key components of portfolio attribution analysis, selecting appropriate attribution models, and being aware of its limitations and challenges can help investment managers make better-informed decisions and improve their investment process.

As the investment landscape evolves, innovations in portfolio attribution analysis will continue to emerge, providing new insights and opportunities for investment managers to enhance their performance.

Portfolio Attribution Analysis FAQs

true-tamplin_2x_mam3b7

About the Author

True Tamplin, BSc, CEPF®

True Tamplin is a published author, public speaker, CEO of UpDigital, and founder of Finance Strategists.

True is a Certified Educator in Personal Finance (CEPF®), author of The Handy Financial Ratios Guide, a member of the Society for Advancing Business Editing and Writing, contributes to his financial education site, Finance Strategists, and has spoken to various financial communities such as the CFA Institute, as well as university students like his Alma mater, Biola University, where he received a bachelor of science in business and data analytics.

To learn more about True, visit his personal website or view his author profiles on Amazon, Nasdaq and Forbes.

Discover Wealth Management Solutions Near You